Skip to main content
deleted 3 characters in body
Source Link
Chives
  • 3.2k
  • 14
  • 19

Claude Piron, a very famous Esperantist, wrote an essay about this very topic. He provides the following “underlying anxieties” under some people’s uneducated attacks against Esperanto:

  • Avoiding change in the status quo
  • Language as a cared value and sign of identity
  • Fear of risk
  • Fear of direct contacts (inability to hide behind a language barrier)
  • Fear of infantile regression (“It is too simple to express complex ideas”)
  • Fear of inferiority in connection with facility (they think coming up with a more complicated solution would prove themselves to be intelligent, etc.)
  • Fear of heterogeneity/fragmentation anxiety
  • Fear of lowering standards and destruction

To Most if not all of the criticisms that arise from these are not based on actual facts about the language. I highly recommend reading the essay.

Claude Piron, a very famous Esperantist, wrote an essay about this very topic. He provides the following “underlying anxieties” under some people’s uneducated attacks against Esperanto:

  • Avoiding change in the status quo
  • Language as a cared value and sign of identity
  • Fear of risk
  • Fear of direct contacts (inability to hide behind a language barrier)
  • Fear of infantile regression (“It is too simple to express complex ideas”)
  • Fear of inferiority in connection with facility (they think coming up with a more complicated solution would prove themselves to be intelligent, etc.)
  • Fear of heterogeneity/fragmentation anxiety
  • Fear of lowering standards and destruction

To Most if not all of the criticisms that arise from these are not based on actual facts about the language. I highly recommend reading the essay.

Claude Piron, a very famous Esperantist, wrote an essay about this very topic. He provides the following “underlying anxieties” under some people’s uneducated attacks against Esperanto:

  • Avoiding change in the status quo
  • Language as a cared value and sign of identity
  • Fear of risk
  • Fear of direct contacts (inability to hide behind a language barrier)
  • Fear of infantile regression (“It is too simple to express complex ideas”)
  • Fear of inferiority in connection with facility (they think coming up with a more complicated solution would prove themselves to be intelligent, etc.)
  • Fear of heterogeneity/fragmentation anxiety
  • Fear of lowering standards and destruction

Most if not all of the criticisms that arise from these are not based on actual facts about the language. I highly recommend reading the essay.

Source Link
Chives
  • 3.2k
  • 14
  • 19

Claude Piron, a very famous Esperantist, wrote an essay about this very topic. He provides the following “underlying anxieties” under some people’s uneducated attacks against Esperanto:

  • Avoiding change in the status quo
  • Language as a cared value and sign of identity
  • Fear of risk
  • Fear of direct contacts (inability to hide behind a language barrier)
  • Fear of infantile regression (“It is too simple to express complex ideas”)
  • Fear of inferiority in connection with facility (they think coming up with a more complicated solution would prove themselves to be intelligent, etc.)
  • Fear of heterogeneity/fragmentation anxiety
  • Fear of lowering standards and destruction

To Most if not all of the criticisms that arise from these are not based on actual facts about the language. I highly recommend reading the essay.